Two Easy Ways to Start Earning Rewards!
Earn 2X Pals Rewards points at Petco
when you use Petco Pay!
Updated on September 23rd, 2025
Pet's info: Cat | American Shorthair | Female | spayed | 14 years and 7 months old | 5.5 lbs
Should a “dead” kidney be removed or left alone. My vet stated that the dead kidney is causing her symptoms (elevated heart rate, abnormal kidney values, appetite decreased, slow but steady weight loss) and that it should be removed. Do you agree? Randi is a fourteen + year old cat and her other kidney is ithe early second stage of kidney failure. I would greatly appreciate your opinion. Thank you.
2 Answers

Answered By Linda G, MS, DVM
Veterinarian
Published on August 8th, 2018
Answered By Rodrigo Roca, DVM
Veterinarian
Published on August 8th, 2018
Hello, sorry to hear about Randi. Its unlikely that the kidney is dead as this could be very severe and cause life threatening risks. If an organ is truly dead, then it needs to be removed as you are right, these toxins can be several dangerous.
Whats more likely to be going on is that Randi likely has a non-functional kidney. The cells are still alive, just not doing their job sufficiently enough. If this is the case, there is no reason to remove the kidney as it is not causing any more harm by leaving it in there. In fact, if your cat has severe kidney disease, then removing a kidney could make its kidney disease worse.
Finally, a nephrectomy (kidney removal surgery) is complicated and not benign by any means. There are greater potential for complications with bleeding and pain.
You should clarify with your veterinarian wether the kidney is indeed dead or if it is just not functioning adequately. Hope this helps and best of luck.
1Pet Parents found this answer helpful