New Cat Toys

Quirky Kitty Jellyfish & Chill Cooling Cat Toys
(0)
$5.99
Petco Multipack Plush Salmon Cat Toy
(0)
$7.00
Petco Americana Farmer Mouse Cat Toy
(0)
$2.50
Max & Marlow Martini and Umbrella Cat Plush Toy
(0)
$4.99

Petco Multicolor Strings Mix & Match Cat Teaser Toy Attachment
(0)
$3.99
Petco Mix & Match Extra Large Cat Teaser Toy Wand Base
(0)
$2.00
Petco Americana Traditional Sailor Mouse Cat Toy
(0)
$2.50
Petco Americana Baseball Player Mouse Cat Toy
(0)
$2.50

Petco Red White & Blue Rocket Ship Cat Teaser Toy
(0)
$2.50
Max & Marlow Champagne and Strawberry Cat Toys
(0)
$4.99
Petco Interactive Cat Teaser Glove Toy with 5 Attachments
(0)
$10.99
Petco Fruit Plush & Ball Cat Toy Variety Multipack
(0)
$7.99
PawsPik Green Interactive Hide & Seek Concealed Feather Cat Toy
(0)
$32.99
Petco Giraffe Tail Mix & Match Cat Teaser Toy Attachment
(0)
$3.99
Petco Americana Movie Star Mouse Cat Toy
(0)
$2.50
Nala Disc Launcher & Laser Cat Toy
(2)
$19.99
Petco Strawberries Cat Toy Multipack
(0)
$4.99
Max & Marlow Blue-and-White Cat Wand Toy with Plush Toy For Cats
(0)
$4.99
Petco Salmon Fishing Pole Interactive Teaser Cat Toy
(0)
$12.00
Petco Americana Football Player Mouse Cat Toy
(0)
$2.50
Quirky Kitty Cooling Ocean-Themed Design with Pufferfish Pals Catnip Cat Toys
(0)
$5.99
Quirky Kitty Catnip with Manta Ray Cooling Wand Cat Toys
(0)
$8.99
Petco Plush Mice & Variety Ball Cat Toy Multipack
(0)
$13.99
PawsPik Interactive Rechargeable Exercise Tumbler Cat Toy
(0)
$27.99 was $29.99
Petco Fluffy Tail Mix & Match Cat Teaser Toy Attachment
(0)
$3.99
PawsPik Interactive 4-in-1 Laser & Hide & Seek Rechargeable Automatic Cat Exercise Toy
(0)
$29.99 was $34.99
Max & Marlow Interactive Olive Cat Laser Toy with Keychain
(0)
$6.99
Petco Zebra Tail Mix & Match Cat Teaser Toy Attachment
(0)
$3.99
Max & Marlow Colorful Assorted Cat Toy
(0)
$8.99
PawsPik Suction Cup Cat Laser Toy
(0)
$22.99
Meowijuana Get Dunk'd Coffee & Donut 2-fer Cat Toy
(0)
$10.99
Max & Marlow Yellow and White Cat Wand Toy with Plush Toy
(0)
$4.99
Quirky Kitty Catnip & Cooling Ocean-Themed Characters with Cool Shark Wand Cat Toys
(0)
$8.99
Quirky Kitty Catnip & Cooling Materials with Fresh Lobster Kicker Cat Toys
(0)
$7.99
Petco Caterpillar Kicker Cat Toy
(0)
$9.99
Meowijuana Knock 'n' Nibble Boba Tea Treat Dispensing Cat Toy
(0)
$11.99
Petco Multipack Scratcher and Tinned Fish Cat Toy
(0)
$10.00
Petco Coil Snake Cat Toy Pack
(0)
$7.99
Meowijuana Get Kickin Green Lizard Refillable Cat Toy
(0)
$10.99
Pets First NFL Buffalo Bills Cat Wand
(0)
In-Store Only

Quirky Kitty Chilly Chasers Freezable Cat Toys
(0)
$8.99
Quirky Kitty Catnip Seaweed Tumblers Interactive Cat Toys
(0)
$5.99
Quirky Kitty Catnip with Otterly Cool Ocean-Themed Cooling Cat Toys
(0)
$5.99
FIFA World Cup 2026 Feline Dangler Play Lounge for Cats
(1)
$25.00
Petco 3 for $6 Banana Mouse Cat Toy
(0)
$2.50
Petco 3 for $6 Coil Seahorse Cat Toy
(0)
$2.50
Petco 3 for $6 Strawberry Mouse Cat Toy
(0)
$2.50
Petco 3 for $6 Coil Frog Cat Toy
(0)
$2.50

Quirky Kitty Jellyfish & Chill Cooling Cat Toys

Petco Multipack Plush Salmon Cat Toy

Petco Americana Farmer Mouse Cat Toy

Max & Marlow Martini and Umbrella Cat Plush Toy

Petco Multicolor Strings Mix & Match Cat Teaser Toy Attachment

Petco Mix & Match Extra Large Cat Teaser Toy Wand Base

Petco Americana Traditional Sailor Mouse Cat Toy

Petco Americana Baseball Player Mouse Cat Toy

Petco Red White & Blue Rocket Ship Cat Teaser Toy

Max & Marlow Champagne and Strawberry Cat Toys

Petco Interactive Cat Teaser Glove Toy with 5 Attachments

Petco Fruit Plush & Ball Cat Toy Variety Multipack

PawsPik Green Interactive Hide & Seek Concealed Feather Cat Toy

Petco Giraffe Tail Mix & Match Cat Teaser Toy Attachment

Petco Americana Movie Star Mouse Cat Toy

Nala Disc Launcher & Laser Cat Toy

Petco Strawberries Cat Toy Multipack

Max & Marlow Blue-and-White Cat Wand Toy with Plush Toy For Cats

Petco Salmon Fishing Pole Interactive Teaser Cat Toy

Petco Americana Football Player Mouse Cat Toy

Quirky Kitty Cooling Ocean-Themed Design with Pufferfish Pals Catnip Cat Toys

Quirky Kitty Catnip with Manta Ray Cooling Wand Cat Toys

Petco Plush Mice & Variety Ball Cat Toy Multipack

PawsPik Interactive Rechargeable Exercise Tumbler Cat Toy

Petco Fluffy Tail Mix & Match Cat Teaser Toy Attachment

PawsPik Interactive 4-in-1 Laser & Hide & Seek Rechargeable Automatic Cat Exercise Toy

Max & Marlow Interactive Olive Cat Laser Toy with Keychain

Petco Zebra Tail Mix & Match Cat Teaser Toy Attachment

Max & Marlow Colorful Assorted Cat Toy

PawsPik Suction Cup Cat Laser Toy

Meowijuana Get Dunk'd Coffee & Donut 2-fer Cat Toy

Max & Marlow Yellow and White Cat Wand Toy with Plush Toy

Quirky Kitty Catnip & Cooling Ocean-Themed Characters with Cool Shark Wand Cat Toys

Quirky Kitty Catnip & Cooling Materials with Fresh Lobster Kicker Cat Toys

Petco Caterpillar Kicker Cat Toy

Meowijuana Knock 'n' Nibble Boba Tea Treat Dispensing Cat Toy

Petco Multipack Scratcher and Tinned Fish Cat Toy

Petco Coil Snake Cat Toy Pack

Meowijuana Get Kickin Green Lizard Refillable Cat Toy

Pets First NFL Buffalo Bills Cat Wand

Quirky Kitty Chilly Chasers Freezable Cat Toys

Quirky Kitty Catnip Seaweed Tumblers Interactive Cat Toys

Quirky Kitty Catnip with Otterly Cool Ocean-Themed Cooling Cat Toys

FIFA World Cup 2026 Feline Dangler Play Lounge for Cats

Petco 3 for $6 Banana Mouse Cat Toy

Petco 3 for $6 Coil Seahorse Cat Toy

Petco 3 for $6 Strawberry Mouse Cat Toy

Petco 3 for $6 Coil Frog Cat Toy

Related Searches