I recently received the Whole Hearted Peanut Butter cookies as a gift and I’m very happy I did. I have a small Pomeranian that doesn’t eat peanut butter flavored items. My dog loves these. It could be due to them being made with real peanut butter. The cookies are as big as a human cookie so this can be difficult for a small dog. Luckily these cookies can easily break into smaller pieces. My dog was able to eat a whole cookie without me breaking it and she’s ten pounds. The product has minimal amounts of ingredients which I appreciate. The only con to this product from a marketing perspective is the packaging is all pink, very girly. It might do well with a neutral color so it can be gifted to friends dogs that are boys. I’m sure their dogs don’t care though.

Great cookies. Larger size than expected. I thought they would be small for training, but they are a nice size for a reward. They also smell great, a person could easily mistake them for human cookies!

My dog was very excited to get a cookie after her nail trim. They smell nice (unlike some meat-based treats) and have 6 in a bag. They are pretty big treats! I wouldn’t use them for training, since it’s not practical to break them down into smaller pieces. But they make a great reward for special occasions or extra good behavior. In my case, nail trims!

I thought these would be smaller treats, but they’re actually pretty big biscuits. Only about 6 per package. I haven’t really met a treat that my dog doesn’t love, and these certainly fit the bill. Great for stuffing into a toy to keep them busy as well.

A dog cookie that smells good? That is something that is sometimes hard to find but these Whole hearted sandwich cookies smell great. They must taste great too because my dog eats them up. They contain real peanut butter and honey. These are not an everyday training treat because they are higher in calories than some other treats. But, for "special" occasions, these are perfect.

My dogs love these peanut butter cookie treats. They are kind of hard for my smaller older dog to eat because they are very hard, theyre not easy to break in half either. I was expecting them to smell more peanut buttery than they do but my dogs didn't seem to mind

While I don’t advise doing so these cookies look almost good enough for humans to eat. This is a decently sized round peanut butter sandwich, cookie that brings my dog running to the bag every time I pull it out of the cabinet. The cookies don’t last long in our house, because she will happily gobble one or two as a treat after a successful walk

My dog loved these. He practically swallowed them whole everytime we gave him one. Another plus is that they didn't make too big of a mess if they break apart. The only downside would be to potentially make them a little bigger to me more "big dog" friendly.