Different than the ones that i bought a while back. I think they have changed the formula. The biscuits are much thinner than before. The dog seems to still like it for now and that's all that matters

Love these treats! Good healthy treats for my best friend and they don't make his breath stink!!

These are perfect for my dog who has a very limited diet due to his liver issues. He absolutely loves these and they're the perfect crunchy treat to clean his teeth as well. I love that they are 100% pumpkin and nothing else which is great for him.

Our pups both loved beef liver bark. Our PETCO has been out of it. We tried the Venison - and it took them a bit to crave that. One of them isn’t taking to the pumpkin. Just leaves it.

My picky eating cockapoo loooves these! I alternate these with another treat and he favors these ones. Plus the ingredients are good.

My dogs love these treats & since they're pure pumpkin it doesn't upset their stomachs

Healthy with simple ingredients for my senior husky

I'm a fan of this treat as it does have some real values and the dog surprisingly seems to like this non-smelly or animal scent item. It has a nice smell to it (for humans) and easy to break for smaller treats. If there is a challenge, sometimes when a piece is broken the edges and 'corners' can be a bit to the sharp side. Overall, a good product and for some a very healthy product for the fiber.