My dogs love these, but they are very small. I use pizzle sticks as a high value treat and to keep my dogs occupied when needed. These aren’t big enough to last more than a minute.

To be honest, I buy/bought these to give too my dogs (both shih tzu), so they’ll calm down and stop barking when I get home from work… the last time I gave them these though, my male started gasping for air, stumbling around frantically, all while making a muffled whimpering noise! I panicked, not knowing what to do, too upset to make a definitive decision too get into the car and go to an emergency veterinary clinic or too try to get it out myself… as he struggled and panicked more violently, I just lodged several fingers down his throat, held him upside down and started beating his back, without thought, and thank goodness, this ‘treat’ became un-lodged from his lower throat area (I could feel it externally)! I suppose he had a partial blockage, as he was able to make a faint whining noises, or I probably would not have been able to successfully dislodging this thing! I wanted them to stop barking, but not for good lol! I knew these things came with this risk, but I didn’t think it would happen to one of my dogs because they’ve been eating the full sized ones for years, but it did! My advice is… if you have a dog that gets overly excited about eating these (and maybe even gulps these down to steal your other pup’s bully piece) I would ONLY get the full sized ones! Needless to say, I personally will only give a full sized bully sticks (throwing it when it shortens) henceforth, or none at all! I only got the pieces, so I could give it to them in small ‘daily’ doses, but it proved to be a big mistake! These things are just the right size for smaller dogs to chock on!

All the dogs (different sizes) love these! Such a great price too!!

made my dog throw. was definitely this product as nothing else in her diet or routine changed and it happened twice. She's never had a problem with any other bully sticks in the past and they are her favorite treat. Will toss the 2 bags I purchased, and recommend avoiding!

Our dogs liked these bulky sticks, but they’re not always available in store.

Great treat for moderate chewers , and helps to keep them busy for sometime. , but this time around, there was a strong smell when the pack was opened. Not sure if it’s the preservatives but there was a very strong smell unlike prior packs that we have ordered.

I'm happy with the the ordering and the delivery. I just wish the product was like the picture. The bites are so small some are just a little round piece with curly sharp edges. I'm afraid my little one is going to cut her mouth or choke to death. I bought 4 bags and they are all the same. So what I'm trying to say they are nothing like the picture ! The picture is very deceiving !

I used to love those and recently bought 5 packages so that I would be stocked up for awhile. However my dog has gotten sick twice now from the current bag. I will no longer be giving these to my dog and will be returning all of my unopened bags.