Pup loves it. A bit on the soft side. Devoured most on the first evening. That makes these too expensive to buy regularly.

My dog loved these, but several small pieces splintered off and I had to take it from him after only a few hours of use (over 2 weeks)

Much smaller than expected for the price. Ordered a Large and it was super thin and was as long as my hand from finger tip to base plus about an inch. For about $25 that was much less than expected and much less than purchased from other brands. He's hardly touched it. Will try another brand.

Terrible. I bought the biggest baddest antler for my 1 year old Shepard as an early Xmas present. I had to take away the last bit of it about 2 hours after I gave it to him. I thought this was extremely fast! Maybe most of it consist of bone marrow? Well he’s been throwing this up all night. Hopefully this won’t turn into an expensive holiday vet visit. I will never buy an antler of any kind from petco. $40 in store for this?

My dog chewed this up in less than 5 minutes. All that was left was a sharp toothpick.

This was definitely not the right one for my pit mix. While the full antlers have proven the only match for her strong teeth and jaw, the split bone is not nearly as sturdy and not as sturdy as advertised. She ate through 1/3 of the entire soft center of the bone within about 30 min (with the full antler she could chew for a good hour and barely make any dent) and then was ill afterward. For very tough chewers we do not recommend Esp given the high price.

Five stars for the product, 1 star for the manufacturer. This item is labeled as 5 oz but you'll see in my photo it was 2.75 oz. Took it back to the store to exchange it for the right product and all the elk antlers with the same bar code are the same size: labeled 5 oz online, "large" on the tag, but actually 2.75 oz. The store associate was very helpful and refunded me the difference in the large to medium size (which is listed as 2.75 oz online) but explained he wouldn't be able to do it again in the future (totally understandable). I've gone to purchasing my elk antlers online, not through Petco, where I get what I pay for because my dog LOVES them. I'm going to assume the manufacturer made an error and not that they're trying to pull one over on us. For the record, I don't fault Petco but they need to be aware of the manufacturer's error.

my dog didn't even acknowledge it. it has been sitting in the same spot on the floor since we got it