My dog did like these so 2 stars. It caused her poop to be liquid and the same bagel color the next morning but I'm not dinging the rating for that. The main reason I don't likd this is that it's advertised as a a "long lasting chew" so I expected something like a bully stick, sweet potto teething ring or a whimzee (all bought from petco)... my 13lb dog is not an aggressive chewer I give her a chew treat for 10-30min a day almost everything i bought is used for a week to a month. comparing it to those things: Whimzee XS: $0.75ea - 44cal - lasts 2hours of chewing. Bully stick: $5 - 78cal - lasts 6hours of chewing GL Sweet Potato Ring: $1.50ea - lasts 3 hours of chewing Bagel Dog Chew = $5 - 187cal - lasts 10min of chewing and another 5-10min to go back and eat all the shreds left behind. She only eats 350cal/day so this is more calories than half her food without any of the vitamins she needs.

got this for my dog and he only had about half (he's 13lbs and poodle-maltese mix) yesterday but had diarrhea last night and twice this morning however! he loved the bagel so at least it tastes good to them

King eats these like candy. They ate easy for him to chew up and digest.

I always get earth animal chews but decided to get this. It instantly upset my dogs stomach. Vomiting and diarrhea, this never happens. Please avoid this treat

King loves these. They are easy to eat. And digest.

King loves these too! They are easy for him to chew up. And they never seem to be a problem digesting.

Bought this for my 5 almost 6 month old puppy earlier today. She’s already thrown up 4 times. Not sure why, she loves new foods and picked this out at the store. I feel bad that she is so sick.

These are easy for King to chew and digest. Give them a try.