the metal hook works great if you’re constantly wearing pants with belt loops. otherwise, the plastic pant clip does NOT hold on to your pocket/waistband. especially if you bend over it will just fall off. i like to wear comfy pants when i walk my dog, but now have to wear jeans whenever i go out. and discomfort myself so the product will work. wish i could return.

Needs 2 straps positioned higher up as the pouch falls off and you also loose the contents as it sits hanging down. I like the inner removal part to clean quickly though.

I used this for about a month before it became unusable. The top drawstring broke, the clip constantly fell off / wouldn’t stay on my belt and holes developed in the interior pocket. Not a very sturdy pouch. I will be buying a different product.

I bought this at the recommendation of our dog trainer Carrie, a petco trainer (side note: she’s amazing!) and it’s been great for training our 5 month old puppy.

Do not buy this. It is remarkable that such a simple product could be made to function so poorly. The clip slides out every single time I use the bag - and is quite difficult to slide back in! The bag also loves to flip upside-down and dump all of your treats out onto the sidewalk. Buy literally any other treat bag - I've never had a problem with other brands.

Haven't ben able to use it on walks , too hot. Have to wait a couple of months.

I've been searching for a zippered treat bag and they've been impossible to find. Finally settled on this; I purchased it on a Friday and the drawstring broke on Monday. I know it's cheap, but was expecting it to last longer than two days.

Training is much easier with a treat back that cinches and can be clipped to my coat or belt. Well made and waterproof it has made training easier.