My dog likes the chicken apple ones but hasn’t been very motivated by these. I’m also confused why they have garlic powder. I wish I had noticed that before buying.

My pup loves these. Good training treats and three calories per treat. Bad part is that the site said buy one get one free and I only got one .

My pup first got these in a PupBox. Now he can’t resist them. He loves them.

My dog love it! I love it too because he doesn't just swallow it he chews it. Crunch Crunch Crundh

My dog loves Charlie Bear treats in general, but this is one of her favorites. And it has a nice cranberry odor. Unfortunately, PetCo only had 2 flavors of Charlie Bear treats, when I know for a fact that there are many more flavors. Until they get more flavors, it might be easier to order what you want from amazon.

All the pups love the Charlie bears; always a hit. They didn't hesitate with the new flavor

Tried these for the first time and my dogs love them. We usually get the Charlee Bear Liver Flavor Dog Treats but these new one they love too. We can only get the ones with 3% fat so it would be nice if you made them all with only 3% fat since our dog gets pancreatitis.

My dog loves these treats and I have never had a problem with them as I had with other treats.