[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] The ingredients was good and the effectiveness seems good. The packaging could be a zipper enclosure to seal the package. The texture is not very plyable so these are good for dogs that aren't older as my dog took weeks to get through 1. I didn't notice a scent of any kind.

One of these sticks last 25 minutes for my lab. Wish they lasted longer for the price.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] My dog absolutely love the treats. He was immediately asking for them as soon as he saw the bag. he ran with it and ate it all day, it’s his new favorite treat

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] These are great. Comes in a small package 3 a piece. Had great ingredients that my dog loves. Doesn’t have a scent. The texture is a rawhide. Has collagen in it.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] My pup has never had a treat like this and is absolutely obsessed. She loves to chew on these collagen sticks and I even caught her holding it between her toes to keep a close eye on it while taking a break from chewing. I would highly recommend getting these for your puppy to try. No bad scent, my girl loves the texture, appears to have great ingredients and the package is great.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Thank you Influenster and Barkworthies, my dog enjoyed his collagen sticks. It was delivered in a safely manner, sealed tightly so it did not smell. The texture of the beef stick was solid and durable enough for my dog to enjoy it. He gave paw for the treat and looked to have one more afterwards. Give this BW Collagen beef sticks a try, your dog will enjoy them.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] These are HARD! I would say a little too hard. I see on the package they have four varieties and this is the second to hardest. But it did make me concerned that they were so hard they could cause broken teeth. They did last longer than your typical rawhide, but my dogs still finished them in about 5 or so minutes. Good size for 25-30 lb dogs like mine.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I thought that surely my dogs would go nuts over these Barkworthies Collagen Beef Sticks, but it took a while for my dogs to even notice these were treats. They eventually took interest and started chewing on them and seemed interested, but it must not smell super appetizing which was surprising. I like the packaging though it looks like Blue brand which could be confusing to consumers if sold in the store. I like the ingredients - the fact that these are 95% collagen makes me feel good about my dogs eating them. My Pomeranian gets treats stuck in his mane sometimes so I was worried these would, but luckily, they didn’t. I wish there were more than 3 sticks in the package, but they seem longlasting. I’d consider telling others about these, but it seems like my dogs weren’t huge fans initially.